Saturday, October 30, 2010

Unpaid Review- Rider's Rasp

Shortly before we left on the trip of a lifetime, I was called out to trim our Favorite Ponies On The Planet. Their owner had recently acquired a Rider's Rasp, and we had the chance to test it out.

Now, before I go any farther, I will say one more time: This is an unpaid review. The people at Rider's Rasp have not contacted me, and we have no agreement for my review of their product.


The days test subject was the little handsome bugger pictured above. Tiny feet and all, he was willing to be our model.


I liked the fact that there is really no way for anyone to rasp the skin off their hands. The shape of the tool fit my hand well, and was balanced nicely.

That was pretty much where it ended for me though. I understand that there are two types of blades available- smooth or fine (which we had to use,) or more coarse, almost like a real rasp but not as rough.

Maybe it was the size of the tiny hoof. Maybe it was the fact that we had the finishing blades instead of the more coarse blades. (Replacement blades are available for around $20. The tool itself runs around $40.) Maybe I'm just too used to using regular real rasps.

But I was somewhat underwhelmed by the Rider's Rasp.

Would it work for emergency use? Maybe. You'd be there a mighty long while though.

Would it do to maintain hooves between trims? Again, a solid but half hearted maybe. How much is your time worth?

Would it be worth spending $40 on? No- you can get a rasp from your hoof care provider usually for free to touch up any issues in between trims.

My big issues with it?
Small rasp area means a lot more work on your part to get the job done. Even if it is just a minor chip, to smooth out rough edges it is going to take you a good bit of time, versus two or three swipes with a regular rasp.

The cost of replacement blades: for that price, you can get a brand new SavEdge rasp. Which would last your average horse owner just about a lifetime.

The idea was not a bad one. But the execution needs tweaking. I'd like to see a bigger work surface and better quality rasp blades. Just making those two adjustments might make this much more worthy for the average horse owner to keep on hand. And it might go a long ways towards making the initial $40 purchase price more justifiable. But for now, if you want to have a tool on hand in case you need to smooth something out, pick up a regular rasp from your hoof care provider, duct tape the tang (pointed end,) and watch your knuckles.

Again- this was an unsolicited review on this product.

17 comments:

Anonymous said...

I wondered about this. Looks more like a grooming tool than an effective trimming tool.

Ugh, the rasped knuckles. I went to the ER for something else and the doc looked at my hands and asked if I had been in a fight! I can't seem to remember my gloves.

~spotz58

Sydney_bitless said...

Haha the many times I have rasped my knuckles. Even with rubber coated gloves on my good rasp can get em but I don't use gloves much anymore. I am learning I am learning.

Now I had heard a lot about the riders rasp and a friend had one but it did have different rasp heads on it than that one. She seemed to have no problem with it to maintain her horses hooves between trims.

Nikker said...

Good to know! I have been contimplating getting one, as my farrier has offered to show me how to maintain my donkeys between trims...horses too of course.
I am still a big fan of leaving it to the professionals and paying for the service....

Mrs Mom said...

Spotz- I agree there. The smoother finish rasp did make a nice surface, but it took for-ev-er.

Sydney- I think the biggest thing that bugged me about it was the time it took. I like to get in, get to work, and get DONE, as a lot of the clients we have simply can't stand on three legs that long with out difficulty. I like the speed of my regular rasps. The time it took to get a good finish with this one... well... I'm not willing to take that much time.

Nikker- It's always good to learn! ;)

Nuzzling Muzzles said...

I bought the larger one of those a while back, tossed it in my horse trailer, and completely forgot about it. I'll have to try it out and let you know what I think.

My farrier has given me some of his rasps. I have a handle, but the rasp won't stay in the handle and the sharp part stabs me. It's hard to grip, so I'll try your duct tape idea.

Oh yeah, and I've been using The Knife a lot lately. Lostine's heels keep forming these bulbous outgrowths and she actually trips over them. So, I've been sawing them off and she seems to appreciate it.

lytha said...

thank you so much for this review. i've been wondering about this product for a long time.

maybe it's good for those horse people who measure their love for their horses by the amount of time spent doing each horsey task!

Mikey said...

I've always wondered about those too. I'm with you, just use a regular rasp and get used to it. You'll only skin yourself a couple times before you learn :)

Mrs Mom said...

NuzMuz- when you put the handle on the tang of your rasp, twist it on tight a bit, and then smack the handle pointed end down onto the driveway/ concrete/ cinder blocks- anything hard, so you can seat the tang in the handle.

Funder said...

Wow, he's a cute little bugger, but his poor feet!

I dunno, I'm so laissez-faire about chips - what's the point of smoothing out a chip? The damage (if any) has been done. And it seems like that cute little thing would only be good for smoothing chips.

Vaquerogirl said...

Thanks! I wondered how effective it would be and how fast. Now I know I'll stick with my old standby rasp!

Dreaming said...

Well, from the comments I can see that I'm not the only one out there who wondered about the effectiveness of the rasp. Thanks for the great review - sounds like the tool was carefully tested and all angles (yuk, yuk) were considered.

oregonsunshine said...

I am completely clueless about situations I might need a rasp. But then again, the ever-so-wonderful Mr. J. lives just down the road and can be here in 8 minutes, if that.

I really should come spend a weekend with you and learn something.

Jenn said...

I'm glad you posted this. I've been considering a Rider's Rasp but was balking at the price, considering I can get a regular rasp for less than half that price.

Regular rasp it will be for me!

Chelsi said...

Well... if it falls short as a rasp I think I know a few ladies who could use it on her feet! :)

Momma Fargo said...

Glad for the review. Was looking at those. It's all hard work any way you look at it. Have to make it easier on myself in a pinch. But thought the way it was designed would be easier to work. Thanks!

Anonymous said...

My understanding is that this is NOT a trimming tool, but a rounding tool, for touch ups only, between regular trims.

Mrs Mom said...

Yep, and if you read what I wrote, I did not SAY this was a trimming tool. I said several times in there that this was for touch ups. For use in between trims. For use when you don't have a real rasp available to touch up a hoof.

Did I like it? No. But then again- I much prefer a bigger tool with a wider work surface to get the job done quicker and easier.

Just my opinion. That and about $5 might get you a cup of coffee somewhere- take it for what it is.